The San Francisco 49ers are at a pivotal juncture regarding quarterback Brock Purdy’s future with the team. Offering him a multi-year contract exceeding $60 million annually presents both significant advantages and potential drawbacks. A thorough evaluation of Purdy’s 2024 season statistics is essential in this decision-making process.

PROS

Stability at Quarterback
Purdy’s 2024 performance demonstrated his capability as a reliable starting quarterback. Over 15 games, he completed 300 of 455 pass attempts, achieving a completion rate of 65.9%. He amassed 3,864 passing yards, averaging 8.5 yards per attempt, and threw 20 touchdowns against 12 interceptions, culminating in a passer rating of 96.1.

These statistics indicate a solid and consistent presence under center, suggesting that a long-term contract could provide the 49ers with the stability they’ve been seeking at this crucial position.

Rewarding Performance and Leadership
Beyond his passing achievements, Purdy contributed significantly to the ground game, rushing for 323 yards and leading the team with five rushing touchdowns.

His dual-threat capability and leadership qualities were evident throughout the season, even as the team faced challenges. Rewarding Purdy with a substantial contract would acknowledge his contributions and reinforce the organization’s commitment to players who exhibit resilience and versatility.

Market Dynamics
The quarterback market is experiencing rapid inflation, with top-tier quarterbacks commanding salaries around $60 million annually.

Securing Purdy now could potentially be a prudent financial decision, especially if his performance continues to ascend, thereby increasing his market value in the future.

CONS

Financial Constraints
Allocating over $60 million per year to Purdy would significantly impact the 49ers’ salary cap. This financial commitment could constrain the team’s ability to retain or acquire talent in other key positions, potentially affecting overall team performance. The 49ers’ 6-11 record in 2024, missing the playoffs for the first time since 2020, underscores the need for a well-rounded roster to achieve success.

Injury Concerns
Purdy’s 2024 season was marred by injuries, including a right elbow issue that caused him to miss two games.

His injury history raises questions about his durability over the course of a long-term, high-value contract. Investing heavily in a player with a notable injury record could pose significant risks if he is unable to maintain consistent availability.

Performance Variability
While Purdy’s statistics were commendable, the team’s overall performance in 2024 was disappointing. The 49ers’ offense struggled at times, and Purdy’s 12 interceptions indicate areas for improvement in decision-making. Offering a substantial contract based on a season with mixed outcomes may be premature without further evidence of sustained high-level performance.

Conclusion
The decision to offer Brock Purdy a multi-year contract exceeding $60 million annually requires a careful assessment of his 2024 performance, injury history, and the potential impact on the team’s financial flexibility. While Purdy has demonstrated the potential to be a franchise quarterback, the 49ers must weigh the benefits of securing stability at the position against the risks associated with his injury history and the substantial financial commitment. A balanced approach, possibly involving performance-based incentives, could mitigate some of these concerns while acknowledging Purdy’s contributions and potential for future growth.